Pies

Pies

  • On Sale
    Sweetie Pies, Cherry Pie

    Sweetie Pies

    Sweetie Pies, Cherry Pie

    Now: $51.99
    Was: $56.99
      Our hand-rolled crust, chock-full of Door County’s famous Montmorency cherries; red, juicy and perfectly tart. Grown right down the road from Sweetie Pies.   Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in...
    Now: $51.99
    Was: $56.99
  • On Sale
    Sweetie Pies, Pumpkin Pie

    Sweetie Pies

    Sweetie Pies, Pumpkin Pie

    Now: $37.99
    Was: $42.99
    Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll every single crust. In fact, the only piece of machinery we use is an 8 cup mixer just like the one you probably have in your kitchen. Made. With. Love...
    Now: $37.99
    Was: $42.99
  • On Sale
    Sweetie Pies, Apple Pie

    Sweetie Pies

    Sweetie Pies, Apple Pie

    Now: $42.99
    Was: $47.99
    A mountain of crisp apples piled high into our flaky handcrafted crust, perfectly seasoned with our secret cinnamon spice. Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll every single crust. In fact,...
    Now: $42.99
    Was: $47.99
  • On Sale
    Sweetie Pies, Blueberry Pie

    Sweetie Pies

    Sweetie Pies, Blueberry Pie

    Now: $47.99
    Was: $52.99
     Our perfect hand-rolled crust jam-packed with oodles of delectable tangy midwestern blueberries.   Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll every single crust. In fact, the only...
    Now: $47.99
    Was: $52.99
  • Out of stock
    On Sale
    Bea's HoMade Apple Pie

    Bea's HoMade

    Bea's HoMade Apple Pie

    Now: $23.99
    Was: $28.99
    Bea's Ho-made Apple Pie (ready to bake) All of our pies are hand-rolled with a lard crust and made with fruit, sugar and flour which thickens as the pie bakes. 
    Now: $23.99
    Was: $28.99
  • On Sale
    Sweetie Pies, Strawberry-Rhubarb Pie

    Sweetie Pies

    Sweetie Pies, Strawberry-Rhubarb Pie

    Now: $51.99
    Was: $56.99
     The aromatic union of sweet ripe strawberries and succulently sour rhubarb heaped into our flaky butter crust.   Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll every single crust. In fact,...
    Now: $51.99
    Was: $56.99
  • Out of stock
    On Sale
    Bea's HoMade Blueberry Pie

    Bea's HoMade

    Bea's HoMade Blueberry Pie

    Now: $23.99
    Was: $28.99
    Bea's Ho-made Blueberry Pie (ready to bake) All of our pies are hand-rolled with a lard crust and made with fruit, sugar and flour which thickens as the pie bakes.
    Now: $23.99
    Was: $28.99
  • On Sale
    Sweetie Pies, Pecan Pie

    Sweetie Pies

    Sweetie Pies, Pecan Pie

    Now: $47.99
    Was: $52.99
    As we say at Sweetie Pies, “Our pecans go all the way to the bottom!” …loads of them, with just the right amount of gooey sweetness. Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll...
    Now: $47.99
    Was: $52.99
  • On Sale
    Sweetie Pies, Peach Pie

    Sweetie Pies

    Sweetie Pies, Peach Pie

    Now: $51.99
    Was: $56.99
      What do you do with a scrumptious pecan pie that’s already perfect? Add a decadent handful of chocolate chips, of course!   Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll every...
    Now: $51.99
    Was: $56.99
  • On Sale
    Bea's HoMade Cherry Pie

    Bea's HoMade

    Bea's HoMade Cherry Pie

    Now: $23.99
    Was: $28.99
    Bea's Ho-made Cherry Pie (ready to bake) At Bea's we hand-roll our from scratch pie crusts. We make our crusts with lard, not vegetable shortening. It's not a health food, but it makes a wonderfully flakey crust and a delicious indulgence. We fill...
    Now: $23.99
    Was: $28.99
  • On Sale
    Sweetie Pies, Cherry-Rhubarb Pie

    Sweetie Pies

    Sweetie Pies, Cherry-Rhubarb Pie

    Now: $47.99
    Was: $52.99
    Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll every single crust. In fact, the only piece of machinery we use is an 8 cup mixer just like the one you probably have in your kitchen. Made. With. Love...
    Now: $47.99
    Was: $52.99
  • On Sale
    Sweetie Pies, Peach-Cherry Pie

    Sweetie Pies

    Sweetie Pies, Peach-Cherry Pie

    Now: $51.99
    Was: $56.99
    The perfect marriage of our northern tart cherries and sweet southern peaches, heaped into a lovingly hand-rolled flaky crust. Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll every single crust. In...
    Now: $51.99
    Was: $56.99
  • On Sale
    Sweetie Pies, Raspberry-Cherry Pie

    Sweetie Pies

    Sweetie Pies, Raspberry-Cherry Pie

    Now: $57.99
    Was: $62.99
    Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll every single crust. In fact, the only piece of machinery we use is an 8 cup mixer just like the one you probably have in your kitchen. Made. With. Love...
    Now: $57.99
    Was: $62.99
  • On Sale
    Sweetie Pies, Apple-Cherry Pie

    Sweetie Pies

    Sweetie Pies, Apple-Cherry Pie

    Now: $44.99
    Was: $49.99
    Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll every single crust. In fact, the only piece of machinery we use is an 8 cup mixer just like the one you probably have in your kitchen. Made. With. Love...
    Now: $44.99
    Was: $49.99
  • On Sale
    Bea's HoMade Summertime Pie

    Bea's HoMade

    Bea's HoMade Summertime Pie

    Now: $23.99
    Was: $28.99
    Bea's Ho-made Summertime Pie (ready to bake) All of our pies are hand-rolled with a lard crust and made with fruit, sugar and flour which thickens as the pie bakes. The "Summertime" pie is filled with Peach, Blueberries and Cherries.  Yum!
    Now: $23.99
    Was: $28.99
  • On Sale
    Sweetie Pies, Apple-Caramel Pie

    Sweetie Pies

    Sweetie Pies, Apple-Caramel Pie

    Now: $42.99
    Was: $47.99
    A childhood memory; our signature apple pie featuring gooey sweet caramel throughout. Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll every single crust. In fact, the only piece of machinery we use is...
    Now: $42.99
    Was: $47.99
  • On Sale
    Sweetie Pies, Red, White & Blue Pie

    Sweetie Pies

    Sweetie Pies, Red, White & Blue Pie

    Now: $49.99
    Was: $54.99
    Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll every single crust. In fact, the only piece of machinery we use is an 8 cup mixer just like the one you probably have in your kitchen. Made. With. Love...
    Now: $49.99
    Was: $54.99
  • On Sale
    Sweetie Pies, Apple-Cranberry Pie

    Sweetie Pies

    Sweetie Pies, Apple-Cranberry Pie

    Now: $44.99
    Was: $49.99
    Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll every single crust. In fact, the only piece of machinery we use is an 8 cup mixer just like the one you probably have in your kitchen. Made. With. Love...
    Now: $44.99
    Was: $49.99
  • On Sale
    Sweetie Pies, Bruiseberry Pie

    Sweetie Pies

    Sweetie Pies, Bruiseberry Pie

    Now: $44.99
    Was: $49.99
    Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll every single crust. In fact, the only piece of machinery we use is an 8 cup mixer just like the one you probably have in your kitchen. Made. With. Love...
    Now: $44.99
    Was: $49.99
  • On Sale
    Sweetie Pies, Three-Berry Pie

    Sweetie Pies

    Sweetie Pies, Three-Berry Pie

    Now: $57.99
    Was: $62.99
     A tantalizing combination of blackberries, raspberries, and blueberries packed into our lovingly hand-rolled crust and perfectly sweetened.   Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll...
    Now: $57.99
    Was: $62.99
  • On Sale
    Sweetie Pies, Berried Treasure Pie

    Sweetie Pies

    Sweetie Pies, Berried Treasure Pie

    Now: $51.99
    Was: $56.99
    Strawberries are all the difference; our hand-rolled crumbly crust stuffed with blackberries, blueberries, and YES!...strawberries. Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll every single crust...
    Now: $51.99
    Was: $56.99
  • On Sale
    Sweetie Pies, Larry-Berry Pie

    Sweetie Pies

    Sweetie Pies, Larry-Berry Pie

    Now: $57.99
    Was: $62.99
    Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll every single crust. In fact, the only piece of machinery we use is an 8 cup mixer just like the one you probably have in your kitchen. Made. With. Love...
    Now: $57.99
    Was: $62.99
  • On Sale
    Sweetie Pies, Rhubarb Pie

    Sweetie Pies

    Sweetie Pies, Rhubarb Pie

    Now: $42.99
    Was: $47.99
    Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll every single crust. In fact, the only piece of machinery we use is an 8 cup mixer just like the one you probably have in your kitchen. Made. With. Love...
    Now: $42.99
    Was: $47.99
  • On Sale
    Sweetie Pies, Peach-Raspberry Pie

    Sweetie Pies

    Sweetie Pies, Peach-Raspberry Pie

    Now: $57.99
    Was: $62.99
    Our celebrated crust bursting with luscious golden peaches and tantalizingly tart raspberries. Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll every single crust. In fact, the only piece of machinery...
    Now: $57.99
    Was: $62.99
  • On Sale
    Sweetie Pies, Peach-Blueberry Pie

    Sweetie Pies

    Sweetie Pies, Peach-Blueberry Pie

    Now: $44.99
    Was: $49.99
    Opposites attract when delectable midwestern blueberries share the perfect handcrafted crust with barely sweetened southern peaches. Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll every single crust...
    Now: $44.99
    Was: $49.99
  • On Sale
    Sweetie Pies, Chocolate-Pecan Pie

    Sweetie Pies

    Sweetie Pies, Chocolate-Pecan Pie

    Now: $47.99
    Was: $52.99
     What do you do with a scrumptious pecan pie that’s already perfect? Add a decadent handful of chocolate chips, of course!   Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll every...
    Now: $47.99
    Was: $52.99
  • On Sale
    Sweetie Pies, Chocolate Chess Pie

    Sweetie Pies

    Sweetie Pies, Chocolate Chess Pie

    Now: $42.99
    Was: $47.99
    Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll every single crust. In fact, the only piece of machinery we use is an 8 cup mixer just like the one you probably have in your kitchen. Made. With. Love...
    Now: $42.99
    Was: $47.99
  • On Sale
    Sweetie Pies, Raspberry Pie

    Sweetie Pies

    Sweetie Pies, Raspberry Pie

    Now: $57.99
    Was: $62.99
    Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll every single crust. In fact, the only piece of machinery we use is an 8 cup mixer just like the one you probably have in your kitchen. Made. With. Love...
    Now: $57.99
    Was: $62.99
  • On Sale
    Sweetie Pies, GF Apple Pie

    Sweetie Pies

    Sweetie Pies, GF Apple Pie

    Now: $54.99
    Was: $59.99
    Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll every single crust. In fact, the only piece of machinery we use is an 8 cup mixer just like the one you probably have in your kitchen. Made. With. Love...
    Now: $54.99
    Was: $59.99
  • On Sale
    Sweetie Pies, GF Cherry Pie

    Sweetie Pies

    Sweetie Pies, GF Cherry Pie

    Now: $64.99
    Was: $69.99
    Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll every single crust. In fact, the only piece of machinery we use is an 8 cup mixer just like the one you probably have in your kitchen. Made. With. Love...
    Now: $64.99
    Was: $69.99
  • On Sale
    Sweetie Pies, GF Blueberry Pie

    Sweetie Pies

    Sweetie Pies, GF Blueberry Pie

    Now: $44.99
    Was: $49.99
    Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll every single crust. In fact, the only piece of machinery we use is an 8 cup mixer just like the one you probably have in your kitchen. Made. With. Love...
    Now: $44.99
    Was: $49.99