Halo Top - Peanut Butter & Jelly Ice Cream (Pint)

(78 reviews) Write a Review
In Stock
  • HaloTop Peanut Butter & Jelly


HaloTop® Peanut Butter & Jelly Ice Cream

We’ll keep it simple – we love ice cream. You love ice cream too. We decided to make and craft it so we could enjoy ice cream as a regular part of our diets at just 280-360 calories per pint. Then we noticed it tasted delicious and decided to sell our ice cream. Then we named it Halo Top Creamery. Now, we can’t wait for you to pick up a pint and dig in! Wait, did we miss any steps there? 

For customers who ordered a Free Pint on National Ice Cream Day (July 15th, 2018) Shipping and handling is included in the promotion and your pint will be delivered from 7/17/18 to 8/4/17.


• Gluten Free*
• Kosher*
*Please refer to product packaging for Gluten Free & Kosher Status.

View AllClose

78 Reviews

  • 4

    Posted by Marya3 on Aug 13th 2018

    This is an interesting flavor that held up to the hype. Creamy and tasty ice cream. Love it.

  • 3

    Posted by Bree on Aug 13th 2018

    I love halo top but my expectations were not met with this flavor. It tastes more like plain ice cream. There is sometimes a hint of peanut butter and no jelly flavor.

  • 4
    Peanut Butter & Jelly

    Posted by David Mitchell on Aug 13th 2018

    At first I was unsure if I would like it. The smell and first taste wasn't what I was expecting but I was quickly pleased to find that it actually tastes like a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. Beware, it's very addictive. I finished the entire thing wishing I had more. The only thing I'd change is I wish the jelly were more visible but that didn't affect how much I loved this. Definitely recommended.

  • 5
    Peanut Butter & Jelly Ice Cream

    Posted by Diana Foust on Aug 10th 2018

    Yes, you read that right, Peanut Butter & Jelly Ice Cream. What will they think of next? I will admit that when I first saw this new ice cream flavor I was a little leery. I mean, don’t get me wrong I enjoy a good ole peanut butter and jelly sandwich the same as anyone but as an ice cream? I had to try this out for myself. I have to say it was delicious! Even my youngest son who does not regularly eat peanut butter at all liked it and that is saying a lot. I am not sure how they did it but this ice cream taste just like I was eating a sandwich minus the bread. I had three people testing this new product out with me and we all agreed it could not have tasted any closer to a sandwich without being one. My son who never eats pb&j’s even liked it and said he would eat it on a regular basis if I purchased it. We all enjoyed the flavor and hope to see it in a store near us real soon. Halo Top you did a wonderful job creating this new flavor of ice cream!

  • 5
    Spot on

    Posted by Alisha Henry on Aug 10th 2018

    The flavor of HaloTop PB&J ice cream is SPOT ON! There is no doubt that it tastes exactly like you are eating a straight from Mom, PB&J! They nailed the flavor profile! It is good, it has great texture and the calorie/carb count is fantastic! I don't feel guilty giving it to my kids nor my self! I'm not the biggest fan of PB&J, but the fact that it tastes so spot on makes me want to try EVERY FLAVOR Halo Top offers!

  • 3
    PB&J Halo ice cream

    Posted by Amanda dolan on Aug 9th 2018

    I would give this product 5 stars but even though it was delicious and had a great peanut butter flavor, there was no jelly flavor in mine.

  • 1
    poor shipping

    Posted by Kathy Burton on Aug 9th 2018

    I have no clue what it tastes like. I received it thawed out, not going to eat thawed out dairy products. The dry ice packs were busted so I got a face full of chemicals when I opened the Styrofoam cooler. I have sent emails to icecreamsource and have not had a response. Poor communication and evrn though it was a free pint, I would hate to be a paying customer, especially as much as you pay for shipping. Very disappointed.

  • 5
    Peanut Butter & Jelly

    Posted by Kathy Huffman on Aug 6th 2018

    LOVE this flavor! Tastes exactly like PB&J & will be a favorite!

  • 5

    Posted by Amanda on Aug 6th 2018

    Just received in the mail and already a huge hit. I would not normally purchase this in the store but being able to test this at home I figured why not. This is so YUMMY! I would definitely buy this in the store if I could find it. Protein is a huge plus for me, the flavor is amazing!

View AllClose