$27.00
Description
Our Pies Are Different.
They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll every single crust. In fact, the only piece of machinery we use is an 8 cup mixer just like the one you probably have in your kitchen.
Made. With. Love.
Our crew is a family and we truly love these pies. Every time we make a ball of dough, every time we roll a crust or flute an edge, we do it with love in our hearts and in our hands. Each and every pie is lovingly handcrafted to be shared from our family to yours.
*Gluten-free pies are made on a dedicated day with dedicated utensils. They are not made in a dedicated facility.
Related Products

Sweetie Pies
Sweetie Pies, Cherry Pie
$22.00
Our hand-rolled crust, chock-full of Door County’s famous Montmorency cherries; red, juicy and perfectly tart. Grown right down the road from Sweetie Pies. Our Pies Are Different...
$22.00

Sweetie Pies
Sweetie Pies, Peach-Cherry Pie
$22.00
The perfect marriage of our northern tart cherries and sweet southern peaches, heaped into a lovingly hand-rolled flaky crust. Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie...
$22.00

Sweetie Pies
Sweetie Pies, Apple-Cherry Pie
$20.00
Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll every single crust. In fact, the only piece of machinery we use is an 8 cup mixer just like the...
$20.00

Sweetie Pies
Sweetie Pies, GF Apple Pie
$23.00
Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll every single crust. In fact, the only piece of machinery we use is an 8 cup mixer just like the...
$23.00

Sweetie Pies
Sweetie Pies, GF Blueberry Pie
$25.00
Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll every single crust. In fact, the only piece of machinery we use is an 8 cup mixer just like the...
$25.00
Customers Also Viewed

Sweetie Pies
Sweetie Pies, GF Apple Pie
$23.00
Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll every single crust. In fact, the only piece of machinery we use is an 8 cup mixer just like the...
$23.00

Sweetie Pies
Sweetie Pies, GF Blueberry Pie
$25.00
Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll every single crust. In fact, the only piece of machinery we use is an 8 cup mixer just like the...
$25.00

Sweetie Pies
Sweetie Pies, Peach-Cherry Pie
$22.00
The perfect marriage of our northern tart cherries and sweet southern peaches, heaped into a lovingly hand-rolled flaky crust. Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie...
$22.00

Graeter's Chocolate Coconut Almond Chocolate Chip (Pint)
$7.49
New, limited edition Graeter's Chocolate Coconut Almond Chocolate Chip. Escape to a tropical paradise of frozen delight, combining flakes of grated coconut and our gourmet bittersweet chocolate...
$7.49

Graeter's Dark Chocolate Brownie (Pint)
$7.49
A chocolate lover's delight, our Dark Chocolate Brownie ice cream is packed with soft, chewy brownie bits complementing the richness of the dark chocolate ice cream. Can you really have to much...
$7.49

Graeter's Cookies & Cream (Pint)
$7.49
Chunks of America’s favorite sandwich cookies dunked into Graeter’s sweet ice cream will delight every child, including the one inside you! Graeter’s handcrafted ice cream is made...
$7.49

Graeter's Cookie Dough Chocolate Chip (Pint)
$7.49
Cookie Dough Chocolate Chip ice cream is our classic vanilla base loaded with bits of cookie dough and our signature dark chocolate chips. Indulge and enjoy! Ingredients Cream, milk, cane sugar,...
$7.49

Edy's, Nestle, Tollhouse Cookie Dough (Pint)
$5.59
Baking cookies together is the best, and every kid’s favorite part is licking the spoon. Share even more cookie dough moments when you share a bowl of creamy vanilla ice cream with cookie dough...
$5.59

Sweetie Pies, GF Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
$27.00
Our Pies Are Different.They are truly homemade, and unlike any other pie in Door County. We hand roll every single crust. In fact, the only piece of machinery we use is an 8 cup mixer just like the...
$27.00
Sweetie Pies, Three-Berry Pie
$24.00
A tantalizing combination of blackberries, raspberries, and blueberries packed into our lovingly hand-rolled crust and perfectly sweetened. Our Pies Are Different.They are truly...
$24.00